Skip to main content

Summary and Review of Marina M. Elgawly’s article “ Realism and Arab Nationalism: An Uneasy Relationship.”

    The Article examines how Arabic Nationalism and Realism are related, as from the first look; they do not seem to have correlations, however, throughout the paper we can observe how Arabic Nationalism Ideology changes in our understanding. The author starts with the possible types of nationalism in the region, later we see the development of the Arabic Nationalism ideology thought, accounts of realism, and how real situations differs from suggested ideology.
    The author suggests two types of nationalism, which can be applied in the region: state-centric and transnational. The concertation of the paper falls on Pan- Arabic nationalism, which supports the unification of all Arabs (transnational). The unification here is based on linguistic and historical ties. Arab nationalism ideologists such as Zaki Al- Arsuzi, Sati Al- Husri, Shaykh’ Abdullah Al- Alayili, basically reject the importance of state and race in the formation of nationalism and see race as a tool of imperialist powers. Importance of common language and historical roots are highlighted, especially, because the Arabic language was the unique instrument to fight with increasing Turkification in the Ottoman Empire.  On the other hand, we have “set of normative values”, where Islam is seen to have another crucial influence on Arab Nationalism. The author argues, “Arab nationalism supports the accounts of realism”. Realism poses state as the main actor in the international system, unlike-  ideology, identity, political leaders, and etc., those Elgawly supports by Carr’s argument: “ideological principles are not principles at all, but facades which allow states to pursue their national interests.” That’s why if we compare the real situation and the Arabic nationalism ideologists accounts, the de facto situation is more likely to be connected to realism, the author brings the examples of unstable cooperation in the region, which under closer observation could be considered rather as a ‘zero-sum’ game, but not the means to overcome the national boundaries.
    Leaving the article alone, in my opinion, Arabic Nationalism is a more delicate issue; we shall keep in mind the Turkish dominance over the area for more than 600 years. Undoubtfully, they were no longer confident in their own identity. They were searching for the means to build and re-build the identity.
    However, unification under common Islamic heritage does not sound convincing in the light of the sectarian problem of the Middle East Region. There could be a certain period when Arab states were aiming to find any common grounds to unify in order to resist the West, their common threat. Nonetheless, when they grew stronger, the borders were shaped, they no longer needed to rely on shaky cooperation. Additionally, they are self-sufficient and with rapid economic growth. Hence, they can act separately and shall not be excluded from International Relations. They hardly can adopt the extension of self and transnationalism, which we observe in the European states because it seems they have a bigger potential and self- sufficiency, at least in the contemporary settings. 

By Ekaterina P.

References:
ELGAWLY, M. M. 2017. Realism and Arab Nationalism: An Uneasy Partnership. Inquiries Journal [Online], 9. Available: http://www.inquiriesjournal.com/a?id=1715
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Summary and Review of an article written by Freberg, K., Graham, K., McGaughey, K., & Freberg, L. A. "Who are the social media influencers? A study of public perception of personality." Research in brief.

"Who are the social media influencers? A study of public perception of personality. Research in brief."     The reason why this article was chosen by me is simply because it is good to know the influencers of social media, how the public perceives the personality.  This research consolidates our formal knowledge on the issue and even broaden them by the findings of the researchers.    The scientists are taking a closer look at SMI, it is characterized as a new type of independent third party endorser who shape audience attitudes through blogs, tweets, and use of other social media. The authors say that it is little known about audience perceptions of the SMI. They underline two main perceptions of SMI (1) SMI is competing, possibly hostile voices; (2) recognized the possibilities of forging alliances with SMI to promote a brand or an organization.     The scientists use term ‘ SMI capital’ and draw a correlation with CEO capita...
Post a Comment
Read more

Summary and Review of an article written by Mia Bloom and Chelsey Daymon- “Assessing the Future Threat: ISIS’s Virtual Caliphate."

I start my analysis from what we see first- name. There were multiple claims by countries leaders’ that  DAESH’s 1  days are counted, that the territories were successfully cleared. However, the authors suggest the new appeared threat, which they call ‘virtual caliphate’. It can be more dangerous as it has no real restrictions and boundaries, it is decentralised, thus more flexible by its nature. Writers started from the general perils of the social media, Telegram is seen as a tool in the hands of terrorists due to its unique settings, making it easier to share and impose propaganda on its users. They also explain what is getting done to prevent the flourishing of propaganda, as well as the authors'  idea of  the resolution of the problem. The aim of the researches is “to investigate how Telegram used by ISIS and its supporters and assess what kind of threat the use of Telegram poses for the future.”  Now let me jump to the summary itself. The starting poi...
Post a Comment
Read more